Big Star
Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Artist · chart history · #484 in indie & aaa artist polls

Big Star

Band Memphis Active 1971–2010

Big Star formed in 1971 in Memphis and was active until 2010. Big Star has 36 chart appearances on 23 radio countdowns from 8 stations on RockLists, spanning 2001–2026. The most successful song on radio countdowns is “September Gurls”, which appears on 17 lists with a best position of #65. The station that charted Big Star most often is The Colorado Sound (Fort Collins–Denver, CO), with 9 appearances.

36appearances
23countdowns
9songs charted
8stations
0#1 finishes
2001–2026years

Big Star came together in Memphis in 1971: Alex Chilton and Chris Bell on vocals and guitars, Andy Hummel on bass and Jody Stephens on drums. They took the jangle of the Byrds and the melodic smarts of the Beatles and made something aching and new out of it, the purest American power pop there is.

#1 Record, in 1972, got glowing reviews and then went nowhere, sunk by Stax's poor marketing and patchy distribution. It's a heartbreaker of a record all the same: "Thirteen" is as delicate as a pressed flower, "Feel" and "When My Baby's Beside Me" crunch and ring. Bell walked away, frustrated, and the others made Radio City without him, finishing it in December 1973; "September Gurls" chimes like the best single never heard, and "O My Soul" and "Back of a Car" rock loose and raw. Columbia had taken over the Stax catalog by then and effectively blocked its distribution, and Hummel went back to college.

A third album was recorded that fall of 1974 and shelved, and the band was finished by the end of the year. It surfaced later as Third/Sister Lovers and slowly became a cult classic. Bell was killed in a car accident at 27. R.E.M. and the Replacements named them as an influence in the '80s, and in 1993 Chilton and Stephens brought the band back with Jon Auer and Ken Stringfellow of the Posies, even making a new album, In Space, in 2005. Chilton died in 2010, and Hummel months later.

Written with AI assistance from RockLists chart data, MusicBrainz and Wikipedia.

Songs by Big Star on radio countdowns

#SongStrengthListsBest#1sPeak year
1 September Gurls
875
17 #65 – –
2 Thirteen
515
8 #47 – –
3 The Ballad Of El Goodo
231
3 #140 – –
4 When My Baby's Beside Me
54
2 #575 – –
5 Thank You Friends
40
1 #480 – –
6 In The Street
28
1 #575 – –
7 Feel
25
1 #556 – –
8 O My Soul
7
1 #690 – –
9 Back Of A Car
4
1 #852 – –

Albums with charting songs

Where each song was first released, from MusicBrainz.

Every countdown appearance

Year#SongCountdown
2026 391 The Ballad Of El Goodo WYEP Greatest Songs of All Time
2026 237 The Ballad Of El Goodo The Colorado Sound Top 1055 Songs You Discovered on The Colorado Sound
2026 292 September Gurls The Colorado Sound Top 1055 Songs You Discovered on The Colorado Sound
2025 323 September Gurls The Colorado Sound Top 800 Mood Booster Songs
2025 480 Thank You Friends The Colorado Sound Top 800 Mood Booster Songs
2025 575 When My Baby's Beside Me The Colorado Sound Top 800 Mood Booster Songs
2024 556 Feel The Best Opening Tracks of All Time
2024 690 O My Soul The Best Opening Tracks of All Time
2023 263 Thirteen 90.9 The Bridge Top 909 Songs of All Time
2023 612 September Gurls 90.9 The Bridge Top 909 Songs of All Time
2023 849 September Gurls WYEP Countdown to Fall 2023
2023 575 In The Street The Colorado Sound Top 800 Songs About Places
2022 122 September Gurls The Colorado Sound Top 1055 Colorado Sound Songs of All Time
2022 134 Thirteen KEXP Top Songs of the Last 50 Years (1972-2022)
2022 140 The Ballad Of El Goodo The Colorado Sound Top 1055 Colorado Sound Songs of All Time
2022 564 Thirteen The Colorado Sound Top 1055 Colorado Sound Songs of All Time
2022 942 September Gurls WYEP Countdown to Fall 2022
2022 47 Thirteen 90.9 The Bridge Top 909 Songs of the '70s
2022 65 September Gurls 90.9 The Bridge Top 909 Songs of the '70s
2020 301 Thirteen WXPN 2020 Greatest Songs of All Time
2020 505 September Gurls WXPN 2020 Greatest Songs of All Time
2019 529 September Gurls WYEP Labor Day Weekend Countdown 2019
2019 529 September Gurls WYEP Big Spring Countdown 2019
2018 516 Thirteen The Current's 893 Essential Songs
2018 557 September Gurls The Current's 893 Essential Songs
2016 856 September Gurls WYEP 913 Countdown 2016
2014 325 September Gurls WXPN 885 All-Time Greatest Songs (2014)
2014 584 Thirteen WXPN 885 All-Time Greatest Songs (2014)
2012 793 September Gurls WXPN 885 Greatest Rock Songs (2012)
2010 852 Back Of A Car WXPN 885 Ultimate Road Trip Songs (2010)
2006 487 Artist ranking WXPN 885 All-Time Greatest Artists (2006)
2004 334 September Gurls WXPN 885 All-Time Greatest Songs (2004)
2003 1195 September Gurls Fred XM Top 2044 Songs of All-Time (July 2003)
2003 1511 When My Baby's Beside Me Fred XM Top 2044 Songs of All-Time (July 2003)
2001 647 September Gurls WFPK 2001 Greatest Songs of All Time
2001 654 Thirteen WFPK 2001 Greatest Songs of All Time

Comments

Log in or create a free account to join the conversation about Big Star.

Be kind and stay on topic. Guidelines

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.